I’ve just finished a 45-minute lesson in which students learn to distinguish scholarly, trade, and popular resources.
Me: Can you find scholarly literature in the library? Students: Yes.
Me: Can you find trade literature in the library? Students: Yes.
Me: Can you find popular literature in the library? Students: Yes.
Me: Can you find popular literature through Google? Students: Yes.
Me: Can you find trade literature through Google? Students: Yes.
Me: Can you find scholarly literature through Google? Students: Yes.
Me (or another voice from the crowd): So why the library? Why are we here?
I love this line of questioning because it seems to change the way that students see me, a librarian. I think that they come to the library with the idea that I’m pro-library NO MATTER WHAT. I’m going to defend libraries existence instead of convince them that the library is a resource to use. It also opens up a conversation about open access and information privilege.
Access to an academic library has clear benefits to the experienced researcher, but students often need to be convinced to take the extra step and try out a library database, to disrupt their Google habit. Librarians choose the best resources, we filter out the garbage. Library databases are structured in a way that we can retrieve valuable information more efficiently through strategic searching. In all three of my most recent classes, students have suggested this information in response to my question. Then I’ve been able to say that, in addition to carefully curated and organized information, the library has access to more information resources because we have paid for access. Resources from the New York Times to the Journal of the American Medical Association require payment for access to full-text content. The scholarly articles that are available online are able to be read through Open Access… the publishers have circumvented traditional publishing means in order to allow everyone to read the work.
I say, “Open Access is an ethical imperative because otherwise only those who can pay have access to the most recent information and so knowledge development is limited to the rich. You are privileged by your access to information based on your affiliation to this institution.”
This is what I’m interested to hear from you, what is the language you use to introduce information privilege to your students? How do you set it up?